TCG Letter #64 / Carpenter Letter #49

Writing to C.S. Lewis, Tolkien critiques views on Christian marriage and divorce, pointing out what he sees as a confusion in the argument presented in a booklet on Christian behavior. He questions the basis of the "two-marriage" system, arguing that it undermines the foundation of Christian marriage as a universal truth and implies toleration of abuse. He suggests that the Christian resistance to divorce stems from a belief that it damages individuals, society, and Christian morals, particularly in the challenging task of raising Christian youth in an environment that encourages inconstancy. The author also expresses discomfort with the dual marriage ceremony involving both religious and state witnesses, viewing it as an abominable and potentially propagandistic practice.

*This draft letter is dated as April 1943 by Hammond/Scull in the J. R. R. Tolkien Companion and Guide: Vol: 1 - Chronology, see entry for April 1943.