Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...9101112
5 October
2024-10-5 5:12:29 PM UTC
Does anyone else with a WM set notice this issue with printing quality of the text? Specifically around pages 200ish of Fellowship….

Looks blurred and thicker font compared to the other pages

5650_670173664297b.jpeg 4032X3024 px

5650_6701736642a02.jpeg 4032X3024 px

5650_6701736642a52.jpeg 5712X4284 px

5650_670173723b0d6.jpeg 5712X4284 px
5 October
2024-10-5 5:17:57 PM UTC
Oh wow that’s a shame. The WM LoTR illustrated by the author editions were plagued by this exact same issue. That’s unfortunate to see it again.
5 October
2024-10-5 5:22:35 PM UTC

Halbarad wrote:

Oh wow that’s a shame. The WM LoTR illustrated by the author editions were plagued by this exact same issue. That’s unfortunate to see it again.

Yup, that would be an instant return for me as there is no way my eyes would be able to take that level of blurring. I will be checking my copy vet closely for this.
5 October
2024-10-5 5:28:49 PM UTC
Wasn’t sure if it’s just mine or they’re all like this. Why is it so difficult for Harper Collins to get their quality control together, it’s a “deluxe” edition for heavens sake.
5 October
2024-10-5 8:02:37 PM UTC
Foxrook

Wow that's bad... Feel sorry for you and others who have to deal with this kind of thing
5 October
2024-10-5 8:14:11 PM UTC
Ugh, more double-printing. I assume there will be 16 pages like that (I guess these are folded from 16 page sheets)?
5 October
2024-10-5 9:49:28 PM UTC
My set does not have this double printing…lucky I suppose.

5090_6701b42b4cda1.jpeg 4032X3024 px
6 October
2024-10-6 1:11:41 AM UTC
Nice! Hopefully it's just mine and everyone else's is fine :) Reaching out to Harper Collins US about my copy personally.
11 October
2024-10-11 5:15:59 PM UTC
Greetings,

Looking at two different vendors’ sites, I see the WM edition listed as having 140 fewer pages (1,332) than the HC (1,472). Are the WM listings omitting the appendices from their page counts?
25 October
2024-10-25 3:29:16 AM UTC
Hi all, does anyone know if HC/WM has plans to release matching versions for The Hobbit and The Silmarillion? I mean illustrated by AL and with the same spine/box aesthetics etc?
1...9101112
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us