Here's one -
The condition doesn't sound all that great -
"minor marks to book covers and pages edges. Previous owners name top FEP of the Two Towers and Return of the King and on page with the Lord of the Rings poem in the FOTR. There is also some ink inscriptions in the FOTR and ROTK volumes on the FEP/inside book cover/BEP, one of which seems to be an illustration of a pyramid scheme and another a list of actors. Maps present in FOTR and TT, not in ROTK."
But what strikes me is that he doesn't mention the fact that the slip-case is not original.
The condition doesn't sound all that great -
"minor marks to book covers and pages edges. Previous owners name top FEP of the Two Towers and Return of the King and on page with the Lord of the Rings poem in the FOTR. There is also some ink inscriptions in the FOTR and ROTK volumes on the FEP/inside book cover/BEP, one of which seems to be an illustration of a pyramid scheme and another a list of actors. Maps present in FOTR and TT, not in ROTK."
But what strikes me is that he doesn't mention the fact that the slip-case is not original.
I think we've mentioned this seller (1973lee1973) and this very item before. DM slipcase, was it not? And, as you say, seller makes no mention of this. Have a look at this sellers items once, and you'll notice them listed & relisted again & again. This has been up on eBay for years; I'm sure it's the same set.
BH
BH
Yes
it was on ebay around 4-6 months ago and sold for £500 . No photo of the pages of names inside! odd that as would be enough to put anyone off. I got original photos and it wasnt good
it was on ebay around 4-6 months ago and sold for £500 . No photo of the pages of names inside! odd that as would be enough to put anyone off. I got original photos and it wasnt good
AU $275, GBP £179.10
TOLKIEN, J.R.R. The Silmarillion. London, George #2248. TOLKIEN, J.R.R. The Silmarillion. London, George Allen & Unwin, 1977. Includes the much sought after large folding map at rear. Royal 8vo. or.blue cl., gilt lettering and design. OCTAVO SIZE. HARDCOVER. (368pages). TRUE FIRST EDITION - FIRST STATE - precedes the U.S.A. and U.K. editions, with the William Clowes & Sons imprint. In the un-priced dust jacket. A lovely clean, firmly-bound and very collectable copy PIX. #2248.
Did not all the 1st printings include "the much sought after large folding map at rear" and I think it is a UK edition?
Trotter: the non-US, non-UK statement is implying, but not stating, that this is the "Canadian" edition i.e. those 1st editions destined for the export market; sellers always state this kind of nonsense. To be honest, I'm really sick of reading these sorts of listings --when are dealers going to stop assuming that Clowes printed books plus unpriced DJs equal "first state". This is not necessarily the case. Look for the errors, by all means, but don't just look for Clowes and prices. Bah!
BH
BH
Hi Khamul,
someone (nudge nudge) should write a definitive article for identifying Silmarillion states.
someone (nudge nudge) should write a definitive article for identifying Silmarillion states.
Hmmm... don't think I'm not thinking about it. But definitive is quite challenging. It don't think it can be done by looking at the books alone; by this method it would be more of an overview, with clearly stated limitations. I'd like to do some research down at some of the printers archives for a start; much in the way Deagol gathered information for some of his articles on his TolkienBooks (--there's a massive amount of work behind those articles.) I'll get round to it some day...
BH
BH