Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...7879808182...162
13 Mar, 2022
2022-3-13 8:39:00 AM UTC
As much as you can keep out of light, I do. I didn’t have this ‘98 set brand new but I have had it a good number of years. I actually didn’t realise how it looked until this picture. It may be the angle and flash too that makes it worse than it is? But yes there is some fading.

4965_622dad9a5e652.jpeg 908X2016 px
17 Mar, 2022
2022-3-17 10:18:13 AM UTC
They are not my latest acquisitions, but I think some of you may be interested.

Sir Gawain and the Green Knight edited by J.R.R. Tolkien and Eric Valentine Gordon.

From left to right:
1st Edition, 1st Impression 1925 / Hardback (Dj fac-simile), OUP
1st Edition, 2nd Impression 1930 / Hardback (without Dj), OUP
1st Edition, 3rd Impression 1936 / Hardback in dust jacket, OUP
1st Edition, 4th Impression 1946 / Hardback (without Dj), OUP
1st Edition, 5th Impression 1949 / Hardback in dust jacket, OUP
1st Edition, 8th Impression 1960 / Hardback in dust jacket, OUP
1st Edition, 9th Impression 1963 / Hardback in dust jacket, OUP

2174_623301f258566.jpg 1890X1760 px

2174_623301f258d90.jpg 2259X1740 px

2174_623301f2593de.jpg 2328X1778 px

2174_623301f259b18.jpg 2100X1624 px
17 Mar, 2022
2022-3-17 10:34:46 AM UTC
That is a wonderful collection
17 Mar, 2022
2022-3-17 2:08:05 PM UTC
Nice to see them all together like that. Very impressive Tolkieniano
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 8:44:56 PM UTC
Just got the collectors edition of the "Maker of Middle-Earth" for my birthday or better I bought it myself for my birthday :)

5295_6234eee561a07.jpg 529X937 px

5295_6234eee566fd2.jpg 497X880 px

5295_6234eee567307.jpg 1559X880 px

5295_6234eee567546.jpg 497X880 px
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 9:07:00 PM UTC
Did you buy this directly from the Bodleian? Or from a 2nd hand dealer?

If from the Bodleian looks like they have about 100 left or so, if they are sending them off in order that is.
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 9:10:11 PM UTC

Mr. Underhill wrote:

Did you buy this directly from the Bodleian? Or from a 2nd hand dealer?

If from the Bodleian looks like they have about 100 left or so, if they are sending them off in order that is.


They are definitely selling them non-sequentially. I bought one direct last week (I finally decided with how prices have gone generally that I probably won't lose money long term). My copy ended up being #216
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 9:14:58 PM UTC

Stu wrote:

Mr. Underhill wrote:

Did you buy this directly from the Bodleian? Or from a 2nd hand dealer?

If from the Bodleian looks like they have about 100 left or so, if they are sending them off in order that is.


They are definitely selling them non-sequentially. I bought one direct last week (I finally decided with how prices have gone generally that I probably won't lose money long term). My copy ended up being #216

Well, there's no way to estimate then...makes more sense anyway, I have a hunch there are very few left at this point.
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 9:21:48 PM UTC

Mr. Underhill wrote:

Stu wrote:

Mr. Underhill wrote:

Did you buy this directly from the Bodleian? Or from a 2nd hand dealer?

If from the Bodleian looks like they have about 100 left or so, if they are sending them off in order that is.


They are definitely selling them non-sequentially. I bought one direct last week (I finally decided with how prices have gone generally that I probably won't lose money long term). My copy ended up being #216

Well, there's no way to estimate then...makes more sense anyway, I have a hunch there are very few left at this point.

I wouldn't like to hazard a guess, tbh. I think they will sell a fair few when the Amazon series hype really kicks in, especially if they publicise in the right place (assuming there are plenty left). Look at S&G where HarperCollins couldn't shift them, but Folio sold a couple of hundred in a couple of weeks.

I will say that in any sane market, I still think it is overpriced by quite a bit. But it is also very nicely executed. It was a nice change to unwrap a quality product after some of the distinctly non-sumptuous garbage of the last year!
18 Mar, 2022
2022-3-18 9:33:13 PM UTC

Mr. Underhill wrote:

Did you buy this directly from the Bodleian? Or from a 2nd hand dealer?

If from the Bodleian looks like they have about 100 left or so, if they are sending them off in order that is.

Bought it directly from the Bodleian. It was faster then I expected it... and didn't had any problem with customs duty as I live in Germany
1...7879808182...162
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us