signature

I dared query it
sellers reply.....
Thanks for your opinion. I've had FOUR other places all certify they feel it's original. It's like I always say...five different people will say five different things. And people are only human....no one signs their own name EXACTLY the same every time. Only robots do that. Thank you again for your input. So far, I've spoken to 37 different collectors, and you are the ONLY one feeling as you do.


someone else email him and see if reply the same ?

I have emailed him as well, suspect I will get the same response.

Mmm suspect so
He should say 2 people have challenged it.......
We will see!

Yeesh, that's a horribly fake signature.

Out of Interest, are any members aware of any US copies of The Hobbit or The Lord of the Rings signed by Tolkien?

I'm thinking he may have signed at least one, though clearly not this item.

I saw a lotr set a while ago, see if i kept a pic

That's a pretty poor fake. Nothing like having to write your third initial twice because you didn't get it right the first time (I actually think it looks like a poor quality pen and done far too slowly, so the ink soaked in). The entire blurb is bizarre and scammy as well.