Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

2020 Alan Lee Illustrated Lord of The Rings set

21 hours ago
2024-12-20 7:23:34 PM UTC

I recently purchased a copy of the 2020 Alan lee Illustrated Lord of the Rings set and upon receiving it noticed a couple of horrible printing errors so I put in for an exchange. The new set came with it's own set of issues (The back endpaper map in fellowship was put in upside down, several pages have the print pretty out of focus, etc.). In trying to choose which set has less issues to keep (which I'm inclined to do as they seem tough to find in the US, it's now out of stock on Amazon where I bought it) I've been reviewing them back and forth and found the headbands of fellowship on the first set to not be long enough to cover the whole spine. Does anyone know if these are purely decorative on these books?

I figure they probably are based on what I've read researching this but I'd like to make sure as this is a decent sized purchase for me right now.

And more broadly, I'm curious, what would make you return a book? I'm leaning more on keeping the first set. It has two and a half pages of barely legible print in The Two Towers and this headband issues, but I think I prefer two and a half pages of really illegible print to the second set that has maybe ten or more pages of more legible but fuzzy, out of focus print. The first is a 7th printing, the second an 8th printing, for what it's worth.

Thank you in advance!

Pictured: The headband issues and one of the printing issues


6047_6765c192a5324.jpg 4000X3000 px

6047_6765c1d810171.jpg 4000X3000 px

6047_6765c3e0df0e7.jpg 3000X4000 px
18 hours ago
2024-12-20 9:37:22 PM UTC
Is that a 5th impression purchased from an Amazon reseller? If so, they are known to be junk. It isn't clear why/how they came to market, but they only show up on AZ resellers. The headband will be purely decorative.

I'd just return both sets and buy from a more reputable source.


Edit: I see you stated the impressions and they aren't the notorious 5th. I'd still return them. Neither are acceptable.
18 hours ago
2024-12-20 9:58:11 PM UTC
I agree, I would keep niether set and try and find a non defective one on the second hand market. There appear to be plenty to choose from.

This site uses affiliate links for which we may be compensated

The Hobbit & The Lord of the Rings (UK, Illustrated, HB)

HarperCollins (2020-06-25)


£120.00 HarperCollins (Other Format) - Availability: Click to check
$204.41 Blackwell's (hardback (slipcased)) - Availability: Unknown
$123.44 Biblio (HARDBACK) - Availability: Click to check
$123.15 Amazon.com (Hardcover) - Availability: Now
£83.30 Amazon.co.uk (Hardcover) - Availability: Now
€144.37 Amazon.de (Gebundene Ausgabe) - Availability: Now
$125.79 AbeBooks - Availability: Click to check
£50.49 eBay UK - Availability: Click to check
17 hours ago
2024-12-20 11:01:47 PM UTC
As someone who also lives in the US, AwesomeBooks.com is the most reliable place (my experience) to get books from. Blackwell is notorious for terrible packaging, and awesomebooks almost always has better prices as well.

If you’re planning on collecting different editions regularly, most would recommend that you never order from Amazon. The sellers don’t do a great job at ensuring you get the edition you ordered and the packaging is almost always poor as well.
8 hours ago
2024-12-21 7:55:26 AM UTC
What a bizarre printing error. It almost looks as if it’s a photo issue at first glance! Trippy.

I mirror what the others have said: return them. You asked what could cause us to return a book? Something like what you got for sure. Some times I’ll let minor things slide. But other times I’ve been known to go through upwards of 5 or more exchanges before I am satisfied. And other times I just have to realize I’m being a customer service and logistical nightmare, and that I need to give up and try another retailer. Some times bad batches in certain warehouses can happen.

I live in the US, and I know AwesomeBooks gets a lot of love around here, they have good prices, but I’ve also had great luck with Blackwells too. Maybe more people can speak otherwise with their own experiences, like Halbarad above me said about their packaging, but I say you can’t go wrong with either one.
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us