23 Oct, 2011
2011-10-23 2:59:13 PM UTC
In the 2002 History of Middle-earth paperbacks from HarperCollins, are the frontispieces included, and are they in color?
Would there be anything else missing, compared either with the print-on-demand hardbacks or the three-volume set?
24 Oct, 2011
2011-10-24 5:15:07 AM UTC
I have just had a look at The Peoples of Middle-Earth.
The text between the hardback and paperback is the same and uses the same page numbers (so the one volume hardback or paperback Index works with both sets of books).
Most of the hardbacks do include some colour plates which are not in the paperbacks. This appears to be the only omission from the paperbacks.
24 Oct, 2011
2011-10-24 7:25:09 AM UTC
Thanks for that!
I'm not a collector; I'm only trying to put together a set for reading purposes, having never read them before. While I'm drawn more to the aesthetics of the paperback editions, it helps to know that they would be missing some of the color plates from the hardbacks.
Maybe this is how one becomes a collector: one version has this, another version has that, and you end up wanting them all.
24 Oct, 2011
2011-10-24 4:44:14 PM UTC
24 Oct, 2011
2011-10-24 9:16:40 PM UTC
Amazing bookshelf that trotter guy has! If I'm not mistaken I even spotted a LOTR first edition set among a lot of other goodies. You should make a page with detailed pictures of your most prized items with a little backstory; I would be interested to read it.
24 Oct, 2011
2011-10-24 9:54:01 PM UTC
Don't encourage him. "I've got an Uncle, who was in this shop, who saw a Tolkien book, and it was like, signed... blah blah..." --yeh yeh, we don't want to know!
(--unless you're going to sell it to me...)
BH