13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 7:49:53 PM UTC
Please excuse me if I am creating a new thread for this, I hope it is appropriate. I just started watching eBay, AbeBooks and auctions and obviously I have never encountered the
1998 quarter leather bound signed limited Silmarillion http://www.tolkienbooks.net/php/details2.php?id=746, not to mention the lovely
1982 full leather http://www.tolkienbooks.net/php/details2.php?id=728. I wanted to ask you what is your experience with them, more or less how many times do they come up?
Moving on to the price, I know that the answer is that the right price is what people are willing to pay.
So I will ask what would you be willing to pay and what would you consider reasonable? (I saw some sold items examples on this site but they are from 2018 or 2012) I know that obviously the 1982 is more desirable but this variates according to it being signed or otherwise. I would be very interested in knowing about your overall experience with these books and your considerations about availability, price and all that comes to mind.
Thanks for your patience, I fancy that you probably answered this questions many a time.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 8:28:50 PM UTC
Fingon's hair wrote:
Please excuse me if I am creating a new thread for this, I hope it is appropriate. I just started watching eBay, AbeBooks and auctions and obviously I have never encountered the 1998 quarter leather bound signed limited Silmarillion http://www.tolkienbooks.net/php/details2.php?id=746, not to mention the lovely 1982 full leather http://www.tolkienbooks.net/php/details2.php?id=728. I wanted to ask you what is your experience with them, more or less how many times do they come up?
Moving on to the price, I know that the answer is that the right price is what people are willing to pay. So I will ask what would you be willing to pay and what would you consider reasonable? (I saw some sold items examples on this site but they are from 2018 or 2012) I know that obviously the 1982 is more desirable but this variates according to it being signed or otherwise. I would be very interested in knowing about your overall experience with these books and your considerations about availability, price and all that comes to mind.
Thanks for your patience, I fancy that you probably answered this questions many a time.
In the current market, I would not like to hazard a guess for either, to be honest. I think I could safely say that it would probably be impossible to get either for less than £1000 (if at all) at the moment.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:07:09 PM UTC
My guess. For Fine Copies.
1998 £1200 to £1500
1982 Unsigned £2500 to £3000
1982 Signed Upwards of £6000
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:09:16 PM UTC
Finding a copy for sale is the biggest challenge. Especially the 1982.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:12:49 PM UTC
Worth saying that I've seen two unsigned 1982s sell for a lot less than £3000 in the last two years (£1500 range), but I'm not sure how that translates into today's market, which seems to be nuts.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:25:16 PM UTC
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:30:48 PM UTC
remy wrote:
Fine Copies?
I don't recall. I think at least one was. Edit:
Khamûl will know. I think one of them was about £1,200 and was posted about on here. One then came up shortly after.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:31:43 PM UTC
Speaking of limited editions of
The Silmarillion, this one's high on my 'Unicorn List' (titles that I'd LOVE to obtain, but most likely won't ever be able to - much like a unicorn lol. Unicorns are sometimes used to describe highly desired, though unobtainable. I see this term often for whisky.)
https://www.tolkienlibrary.com/tolkien-book-store/CLP0188.htm
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:34:33 PM UTC
insurrbution wrote:
Speaking of limited editions of The Silmarillion, this one's high on my 'Unicorn List' (titles that I'd LOVE to obtain, but most likely won't ever be able to - much like a unicorn lol. Unicorns are sometimes used to describe highly desired, though unobtainable. I see this term often for whisky.)
https://www.tolkienlibrary.com/tolkien-book-store/CLP0188.htm
Yes, that's the 1998. I have a fine copy. I wouldn't personally pay £1000+ for one, but the market is what it is.
13 Feb, 2021
2021-2-13 9:44:25 PM UTC