2 Mar, 2023
(edited)Edited by Roäc on 2023-3-2 8:55:45 PM UTC
2023-3-2 8:49:53 PM UTC
I flipped trough my old first editions of LotR and noticed the St George device pictured below. In FotR it appears in my 6th from -56 and 8th from -59 but not in the 12th from -62.
Does anyone know how long it was used and which were the last impressions to have it?
2 Mar, 2023
2023-3-2 8:57:57 PM UTC
3 Mar, 2023
2023-3-3 11:58:09 AM UTC
FoTR on my shelf -
3rd St George device
4th St George device
7th St George device
8th St George device
8th in a 9th dustwrapper - No St George device
10th St George device
11th St George device
12th No St George device
13th No St George device
14th No St George device
15th No St George device
I can't explain the anomaly of the 8th in a 9th dustwrapper - No St George device.
This has reminded me that I am missing the 5th, 6th and 9th impressions, so if anyone has spares of these, please contact me!
(There is a similar trend in TT and RoTK but I haven't checked every copy that I have.)
3 Mar, 2023
2023-3-3 3:28:43 PM UTC
Your 8th in a 9th dustwrapper is most likely the 1960 9th with the printers error of dropping the 8th printing of 1959. Noted in The Tolkien Collector #20
3 Mar, 2023
2023-3-3 4:56:27 PM UTC
So I (probably) have got a 9th after all! Thanks for the useful information, dunedain.
5 Mar, 2023
2023-3-5 12:32:47 PM UTC
Isn't it at the back? 13th impression on page 424 along with the addresses
5 Mar, 2023
2023-3-5 12:48:11 PM UTC
billhinge wrote:
Isn't it at the back? 13th impression on page 424 along with the addresses
I think the logo is at the back of all the impressions on the address page.
5 Mar, 2023
2023-3-5 1:36:02 PM UTC
Roccondil wrote:
FoTR on my shelf -
3rd St George device
4th St George device
7th St George device
8th St George device
8th in a 9th dustwrapper - No St George device
10th St George device
11th St George device
12th No St George device
13th No St George device
14th No St George device
15th No St George device
I can't explain the anomaly of the 8th in a 9th dustwrapper -
My 8th in a 9th wrapper has the St George device. Is your half title page missing, or is it present but without the device?
5 Mar, 2023
2023-3-5 5:43:23 PM UTC
Here's a couple of pics of my 8th in a 9th dustwrapper. As you can see, it is quite clear. There is no St George device on the title page.
6 Mar, 2023
2023-3-6 6:20:20 PM UTC
Hello Roccondil,
It looks like your's is an Eighth in a Ninth Dustjacket. If it was the printers error it would look like the attached 9th in a 9th dustjacket (showing Eighth in 1960 printing)