Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...89101112...16
5 October
2024-10-5 11:36:55 AM UTC
Delivery from HarperCollins ๐Ÿ˜Š

10_670124bc4e9a2.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_670124bc4ea30.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_670124cef2633.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_670124cef26bf.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_670124cef2718.jpg 1620X1080 px

10_670124cef2766.jpg 1620X1080 px
5 October
2024-10-5 1:10:14 PM UTC
Nice comparison photos. Thanks, Trotter
5 October
2024-10-5 1:14:16 PM UTC
Great pictures Trotter, which set do you prefer ?
5 October
2024-10-5 1:22:02 PM UTC
I think the latest set, very impressed so far with them.
5 October
2024-10-5 3:04:24 PM UTC
Trotter, how do the illustrations compare to previous editions quality wise ?
5 October
2024-10-5 3:36:29 PM UTC
The illustrations for all three are different sizes and on different paper, the Folio Society has the best illustrations, but I like both of the other editions. Hard for me to pick ones I like better.
5 October
2024-10-5 5:27:01 PM UTC
Thanks Trotter. Would love if HC released a big coffee table size art book, with Lee, Howe, Nasmith, and anyone else they could fit in.
6 October
2024-10-6 6:58:21 PM UTC
Arrived today. What a gorgeous set - best new Tolkien publication for some time.
6 October
2024-10-6 8:17:12 PM UTC
I have to say, looking at Trotter's pictures of them all laid out, HC really have done a good job of taking Folio's original design (which was always really problematic to my eyes - quarter-binding proportions all over the place, odd colour choice, big for the sake of a big price tag, extremely fragile cloth, 1970s Readers Digest spine design [yep, subjective!], etc) and made the same basic theme look genuinely good [also subjective].

Not sure when I'll get mine (has shipped from HC to the UK folks), but I look forward to receiving them. I will have the in-laws check that the correct three books are present and do a quick QC flick-through for me, though, as I seem to be especially unlucky when it comes to dodgy copies (and that included the Folio 2022, which LEGO cocked up in three different ways with the set I was initially sent).
6 October
2024-10-6 9:40:13 PM UTC
I got mine today and love the books but was a bit disappointed with the damage on the books, would it be petty to complaine about this?

5779_67030370f15d7.jpg 4032X3024 px

5779_6703037d1fc64.jpg 4032X3024 px

5779_670303855d8a9.jpg 3021X2953 px

5779_6703038a2f0bb.jpg 1787X3145 px
1...89101112...16
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us