Tolkien Collector's Guide
Sign In
Tolkien Collector's Guide
Important links:

Guide to Tolkien's Letters
-
Winner of the 2019 Tolkien Society award for Best Website

1...1011121314...16
7 October
2024-10-7 4:50:21 PM UTC
I don't know for sure, but probably somewhere around 20% UK and 80% US, based on the market size.
7 October
2024-10-7 9:13:02 PM UTC
From a collectors point of view would it be fair to say the Harper Collins version would be the better option as there are less of them?
7 October
2024-10-7 11:16:04 PM UTC

Tall Hobbit wrote:

From a collectors point of view would it be fair to say the Harper Collins version would be the better option as there are less of them?

Well, from a collectors point of view, people collect what they want to collect, not just the book with the lowest number of copies printed.

If you are asking what future value will be, possible that the HC edition will retain value better. Hard to say. I assume it will be reprinted ad-infinitum, so I wouldn't hold any great expectation of value increases (though it is possible).
8 October
2024-10-8 5:09:12 AM UTC

Tall Hobbit wrote:

From a collectors point of view would it be fair to say the Harper Collins version would be the better option as there are less of them?

I agree with The late Stu, these are large numbers and if they sell out, will be reprinted. I don't think it matters which one you get.
8 October
2024-10-8 10:14:53 AM UTC
Especially as they seem to have been printed at the same time!
8 October
2024-10-8 11:23:47 AM UTC
Just arrived. Lovely set. No immediate issues I can see :)

5100_670516231c355.jpeg 4032X3024 px
8 October
2024-10-8 6:52:49 PM UTC
Not going to bother asking my in-laws to quality check further (I'll hit up harperCollins if I find any issues down the line), but seem to be the correct books and imprint and packaging seems to have worked. No dents or damage reported by the folks. Purchased direct from HC using the 50% discount.


5837_67057f69af62c.jpeg 640X480 px
8 October
2024-10-8 11:45:31 PM UTC

The late Stu wrote:

Not going to bother asking my in-laws to quality check further (I'll hit up harperCollins if I find any issues down the line), but seem to be the correct books and imprint and packaging seems to have worked. No dents or damage reported by the folks. Purchased direct from HC using the 50% discount.


Very nice, Congratulations and thanks for the update
9 October
2024-10-9 8:28:24 AM UTC
I reached out to Harper collins and it turns out the print run is 10,000 for HC and and additional 10,0000 for WM.

5812_67063ea1de8dc.jpg 1080X1132 px
9 October
2024-10-9 8:44:19 AM UTC
20,000 copies will last a good while before the next printing I’d guess.
1...1011121314...16
Jump to Last
All original content ©2024 by the submitting authors. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us